CFTC Gives Crypto Wallet Developers a New Regulatory Escape Hatch
The U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) just opened a regulatory side door for software developers, allowing some to market derivatives, collect trading fees and avoid registering as brokers. The agency’s Market Participants Division extended conditional no-action relief to providers of “passive software” on Sept. 17, taking a framework originally granted to Phantom Technologies in March and opening it to a much broader group.
Key Takeaways
- CFTC Staff Letter 26-25 gives passive software providers broader relief as of Sept. 17.
- Phantom’s March 17 framework now reaches more developers connecting users to regulated markets.
- CFTC relief lasts until formal rules or guidance replace the temporary staff position.
There’s a catch, though. The software has to stay in its lane. It can connect users with registered markets and pass along their orders, but it can’t hold customer funds, decide where trades go, or tell people what to buy and sell. The move comes right on the heels of the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission giving tokenized stocks the green light to trade through onchain automated market makers and liquidity pools.
The regulatory line the CFTC just drew is surprisingly straightforward. Software can help someone find a derivatives trade, display it, send the order, and even collect a fee, all without necessarily turning its developer into a broker.
The CFTC’s ‘Dumb Pipe’ Test
In layman’s terms, the CFTC is drawing a line between building the road and driving the car. A wallet, browser extension or website can display market data and contracts, let users submit orders directly to registered futures commission merchants, introducing brokers or designated contract markets, and even collect transaction-based fees. It can market those products, too. Under the staff position, none of that alone necessarily forces the developer to register as an introducing broker.
That’s a meaningful distinction for crypto wallets today. Basically, a self-custodial wallet could theoretically put regulated event contracts or other CFTC-regulated derivatives beside a user’s crypto holdings and get paid when customers trade them. The user still deals directly with the registered market participant, while the wallet acts as the front end.
Phantom’s Deal Gets a Much Bigger Audience
The blueprint isn’t new. Phantom Technologies received substantially similar relief on March 17 through CFTC Staff Letter 26-09. That letter covered Phantom’s self-custodial wallet software and its connections to registered derivatives markets.
Six months later, Staff Letter 26-25 takes that concept beyond one company and makes the staff position broadly available to similarly situated passive software providers. In other words, developers no longer need to look at Phantom’s letter and wonder whether the same logic could apply to them.
There’s Still a Regulatory Fence
There are plenty of strings attached. Developers can’t custody the assets backing a derivatives position, generate express trading signals, exercise discretion over routing or execution, or send customers toward unregistered venues. Users also have to onboard directly with registered market participants, while covered providers face disclosure, recordkeeping, and marketing requirements.
Alongside this, it doesn’t suddenly legalize offshore crypto perpetual platforms or give every decentralized finance (DeFi) derivatives protocol a free pass. The relief is tied specifically to software connecting users with registered CFTC venues and intermediaries.
The Escape Hatch Is Temporary
There’s one more wrinkle. This isn’t a new CFTC rule, and Congress didn’t rewrite the Commodity Exchange Act. It’s a staff no-action position, meaning the division says it won’t recommend enforcement when developers stay inside the specified boundaries.
The relief lasts until formal Commission rulemaking or guidance addresses how introducing-broker registration applies to software providers. Phantom’s earlier relief carried the same endpoint.
So developers have a wider lane today, but the paint isn’t permanent. The commodities and exchange regulator has effectively told software builders where they can drive without a broker license while leaving the Commission to decide where the road ultimately goes.
Tags in this story
About the Author
